Marshalls vs. TJ Maxx: Everything You Need To Know

If you have ever been to a Marshalls or TJ Maxx then you are probably well aware that by the time you get to the checkout, your cart contains a pair of adidas sneakers, multiple three-wick candles, oversized bath towels, and some sort of fruit-shaped bag of gummies. None of these items are needed, but somehow upon seeing each dramatically discounted item, became immediately necessary to own. 

No judgment on what you choose to purchase as you aimlessly wander the aisles, but the real question becomes how identical are these two stores? From the layout to the merchandise to the discounts, what sets the stores apart?

We definitely have the answer, but first, a little history. In 1956, Marshalls opened their doors for the first time. Alfred Marshall gathered a group of like-minded businessmen together to open a “Brands for Less” concept and by 1993, the brand had stores in 42 states including Hawaii. 

TJX, a Massachusetts-based company, launched its first store, TJ Maxx, in 1977. In 1995, TJ Maxx bought out Marshalls, which was their largest competitor. TJX also owns HomeGoods, Homesense, and Sierra. Although the buyers for both Marshalls and TJ Maxx are the same, the stores carry different merchandise and have different in-store layouts.

Marshalls

Erik Gonzalez/Shutterstock

Marshalls differentiates itself from T.J. Maxx with a full line of family footwear and an expanded men’s department. They also feature The CUBE, a department specifically for juniors. In fact, Marshalls’ inventory of shoes, particularly men’s athletic designer brands, like Nike Jordans, is so great that this store is where “shoe flippers” usually go to score discounts, then resell their goods on eBay, Poshmark, or Mercari for a tidy profit.

• Shoe MegaShop – Offers thousands of this season’s shoes for the entire family with new styles arriving multiple times a week. They arrange them by style with specific sizes found under each display.
• Men’s Department – Contains a wide selection of men’s suits, sportcoats, and the latest trends.
• The Cube – A junior’s department that is like a boutique within the store. It’s perfect for young women who are looking for trendy, yet sophisticated styles. The Cube features items from all departments in the store arranged by style rather than size and fancies itself a one-stop shop.

T.J. Maxx

Jonathan Weiss/Shutterstock

T.J. Maxx, meanwhile, is where you will find fashionistas, who refer to themselves as #maxxonistas. TJ Maxx is more well-known for designer jewelry and in some locations, The Runway at Maxx, a high-end designer section. Celebrities including Taylor Swift, Sia, Britney Spears, and Prince Harry have been spotted shopping among the discounter’s aisles. 

• Women’s Shoes Only – With a specialization in women’s shoes, there’s something for every woman and every occasion.
• Expanded Accessories Department – Includes fine jewelry such as 14-kt. gold, sterling silver, and semiprecious stones as well as sunglasses and watches.
• The Runway – High-end designer accessories and fashions at T.J. Maxx prices, including Versace, Gucci, Coach, and many more.

Do Lower Prices Mean Lower Quality?

2p2play/Shutterstock

Not at all. Less than 5% of the clothing sold at either of these stores is considered a “second-rate” item. In fact, if the clothing has any sort of defect, the item will be clearly labeled as such. This way, you can rest assured that the quality of the products overall compares to the same products that you find in department stores.

So, how are they able to offer such great discounts? I’m glad you asked. Here are a few of the ways that the TJX family of retail stores are able to offer you consistent discounts of 30-50% off retail costs:

• Buyers are able to buy items constantly and at the last minute. This means they are able to restock stores with 10,000 new items every week, while most major department stores place their orders five to six months in advance. These last-minute purchases allow the buyers to come in a month before the new season and make a deal with major manufacturers.
• Buyers for the TJX brand take advantage of misorders. For example, if a manufacturer accidentally used silver buttons on a designer jacket instead of the requested bronze buttons, it is still a designer jacket and nothing is wrong with the quality of workmanship. It just wasn’t made to the exact specifications of the designer. Buyers swoop in and place offers at a discounted rate.
• Marshalls and TJ Maxx do not advertise the name-brands which means they do not have to pay for these advertising costs.
• The open store floor plan cuts the cost of merchandising.

Items To Avoid

Eric Glenn / Shutterstock.com

Because of the way they source their inventory, Marshalls and TJ Maxx are great places to score amazing deals. But they can also live up to the old adage that “if something is too good to be true, it probably is.” Here are a few things the internet thinks even the most hardline bargain-shoppers should give a hard pass to.

Cosmetics and Hair Products

Because it’s an off-price retailer, both stores pick up all of their inventory that higher-priced stores don’t want or that they can’t sell. Some of these items include last year’s makeup and cosmetics lines. But perhaps the biggest risk to purchasing cosmetic and hair care products at either store is that you run the risk of buying something that’s been tampered with or even used by someone else as a sample. 

Furniture and Bedsheets

While Marshalls, TJ Maxx, and HomeGoods do carry furniture, bedding, and kitchen supplies, these are bargains you’re also better off buying elsewhere. Most of the furniture you’ll find at these stores are either overstocks or failed factory inspection rejects and as a result, they’re often in far-from-perfect condition.

They also carry sheets and bedding in a variety of colors and designs, but you’re also better off giving these items a miss as well. Cheap sheets are made with inferior fabrics that don’t last, so you’re better off spending a bit more for bedding that lasts longer and feels better.

Appliances and Kitchen Supplies

According to the internet, which never lies, you shouldn’t give the appliances and kitchen supplies a second look either. While not all the kitchen items in the stores are flimsy and liable to break, their most inexpensive items are known for not lasting. The same advice applies to kitchen appliances made by unknown brands, which can break down when you least expect it.

Yoga Mats

If you thought yoga mats would be the same everywhere, you thought wrong. There are multiple websites dedicated to what you should and should not buy from the TJX family of stores and the yoga mats are a hard pass. The reason being that the thin material is slippery and does not hold up to extended use.

If you’re a dedicated yogi, you’re better off spending a few extra dollars on a good, better-known brand instead of trying to save a few bucks. In the long run, you could end up spending double because the mat you first bought as a bargain turned out to be terrible, and a second purchase is needed to replace the first.